Monthly Archives: December 2011

Resolutions and Reform

By Tamara

We talk a lot here about reform: change in education. But do those conversations lead us to action? Or more conversation? Not that more conversation is bad. More conversation is often needed to flesh out ideas.

It's New Year's Eve. That time when many of us are making resolutions. Some that will stick, some that wont. This year one of mine is start taking real action based on my education policy conversations. I don't know exactly what those actions are going to be. This is probably the year I take the leap and try some lobbying in Olympia.

What about others? Are there actions you are looking forward to taking in the new year that support your thoughts and conversations here?

Time Management

Time-managementBy Tom

There are about seventeen hours from the time I say goodbye to my students until the time I say hello to them the next day. Of those seventeen hours, I like to spend about eight in bed. That leaves nine. It takes me about an hour a day to commute; dinner and breakfast combined take another hour, and I spend one more hour shaving, showering and performing other “miscellaneous hygienic tasks.”

That leaves me with six hours of free time. But not really; since one of those hours has to be spent at school, according to my contract, and another hour has to be spent at home, doing chores and staying on top of my kids’ homework.

So I really only have four hours of discretionary time each day. Four out of 24.

Continue reading

A New Role

By Rob

Mentor
Some time ago I was struggling to set up procedures during my literacy instruction.  I was attempting to meet with a guided reading group while the reminder of my class was engaged independently in a meaningful activity.  For some students the “independent” activity was a too challenging and they needed support.  For other students it was too easy and they were finishing early.  Other students had difficulty remaining on task and caused disruptions.  These are the challenges of a novice teacher.

All things considered I was doing pretty well but I knew it could be done better.  But I wasn’t sure how.  I was building the boat as I was crossing the ocean.

I spoke with some other teachers and we shared the same struggles.  After I confided in my principal I found this “struggle” reflected in my evaluation.  Prior to that evaluators found little to criticize.  I regretted opening up my practice.

Continue reading

Camp Fired

Picture 1

 By Travis

The message is clear. Very clear.

On the surface, the message comes across as positive, saying there is an organization out there to help children. I am all for helping children.

However, there is hidden message. An agenda, perhaps? This subtle meaning sends its message to the community even if the community does not consciously read it that way.

Continue reading

Motoring Towards Privatization?

By Rob

Tom has written some thoughtful posts (here, here, and here) about charter schools.  When I read about charter schools with a cohesive staff, a common vision, and high standards for all I’m excited about the possibilities for their use in education reform.  I am also a firm believer that the same reforms are possible for public schools. 

If charter schools take hold then resources will shift towards making them viable.  Who provides the transportation?  Who maintains the facilities?  Who provides the special education services in the least restrictive environment?  Who provides the oversight?  Undoubtedly answers to these questions are possible.  But what if the resources used to address these questions were invested in local school improvement?

Continue reading

The Achievement Gap Between African Americans and African Immigrants

Trust2By Tom

The Seattle Times came out with a story today about the “Alarming” achievement gap between African American students and the children of African immigrants. Apparently the Seattle School district studied their data and found that African American students perform significantly worse than their African classmates, even when you control for factors such as income and single-parent families.

I’m glad the Times ran this article. It’s hard – not to mention awkward – to generalize when you’re talking about something as emotionally charged as race, but when something like this comes along, you sort of have to. That is, after all, the whole point of analyzing data.

Most teachers have noticed this phenomenon for years. I certainly have. Our school has a large proportion of both populations, and most African immigrants are among the most motivated students in the school. Their parents push them hard and are very supportive of everything we do in school. In talking with these parents, I’ve always gotten the sense that educational opportunity was one of the main reasons for their being here, and they have no intention of watching their children squander that opportunity. I get the feeling, from working with many of these families, that they genuinely trust the teachers, the schools and the entire educational system.

As we know all too well, African American families don’t exactly share that same trust of our educational system. Nor should they; our educational system hasn’t exactly spent the past two hundred years earning that trust. There's no question but that this lack of trust interferes with their children's success in school. It's unfortunate, it's sad, but it's true.

What this data shows is that success in school has nothing to do with race. It might have something to do with poverty, but it has everything to do with the relationships between our schools and our families.

What I want to know is this: where do we go from here? How do we build productive relationships with all of our families so that every child succeeds? 

 

It’s the Principal of the Matter

Picture 1By Travis

Principals are near useless. Near…I would not be so mean as to say totally. I know they serve a purpose. But, hey, let’s be honest. How often is your principal in your classroom? If you are lucky, it is twice a year for the district mandated formal observation. Principals do not teach classes so how could a principal possibly understand life in your classroom? They cannot relate. When seen in the big picture, principals do not do much to impact instruction, and as such, are near useless.

However, my principal is not. Lisa teaches.

Continue reading

What We Expect from Teachers or What We Expect from Ourselves

By Tamara

For the last few weeks I have been reflecting on Tom’s observations and analysis of charter schools. Rather than the question about the role charter schools should or shouldn’t play in Washington, what has had me thinking most is the question of what society should expect from teachers. Tom repeatedly noted the time and energy he observed both public and charter school teachers committing. In our comments-based conversation he concluded that truly high caliber teaching does not co-exist well with family life. Agreed.

Yet I wonder: is that right? While there are certainly professions where those with family need not apply, should teaching be one of them?  Many of us here have discussed how being parents make us better teachers. I know when I feel like I am having an “off” teaching day, I think about what I expect from my own child’s teacher. What do I want them to do for my child? Sacrificing their family is never on the list.

 

It is simply difficult for me to accept the idea that having a family (or a life outside the professional day) means one can’t be a high caliber teacher.  It just doesn’t play out in my day to day observations. When I think of the best teachers I work with, most have families and full post-school day lives. It is also difficult for me to accept the notion that any profession should eclipse personal life. Yes we expect long hours and exacting attention to detail from our doctors, emergency responders and our elected officials. But don’t we also expect them to attend to their personal needs as well? I don’t want a burned out doctor doing surgery on me or anyone else. I don’t want elected officials making life-altering policy on a steady diet of all-nighters. And I certainly don’t want a resentful, stressed out teacher educating my child. I don’t want to be a resentful, stressed out teacher!

 

Maybe it’s not a question of what society expects from teachers. Maybe the question is what do we expect the role of work to play in our lives?  I think about how we introduce ourselves: “My name is Jane Doe and I am insert profession here.” We identify ourselves by what we do.  Whereas many other societies identify themselves by who they are: “My name is ______, I am the son of insert three generations of family names here.” So maybe the question is more about are we living to work or working to live?

 

At the end of the discussion I believe there has to be a balance. Will there be sacrifices? Of course.   Yet I maintain there has to be a way to be the best professionals we desire to be without it coming at the complete expense of our personal lives.

 

 

 

Passion Driven Conversation

BA_Good_Listener_posterBy Kristin

I admit, when my friend read this to me there was a moment – about when he read "Being an educator means that you are a part of the noblest profession … Quite frankly it takes a special person to be an educator," – that I started thinking of the bills I've paid this month and the bills I have yet to pay. Teachers are either noble or destroying children, it seems, and I think reality is that we're all in a middle ground. Am I noble if I'm tired of looking at essays instead of my daughters?  I don't think so.  Am I destroying children if I often put the grading down and read Go Dog, Go?  I don't think so.

But by the end, I admit it, I was inspired.  I love when I'm proven wrong.  This high school principal's essay got me where it counts when he wrote, "The educator that I just described … will … never fall victim to the bitterness."  "Ouch!" I thought.  I don't want to be that teacher!

Continue reading

This Is What I’m Talking About

Asa-Mercer-portrait-WEBBy Tom

In case you missed it, there was a wonderful article in the Seattle Times about Asa Mercer Middle School, named after the guy in the picture. Asa Mercer – the school, not the guy – went from being the poster child of woeful, inner-city education to one of the best schools in the Seattle School District. In only six years.

So how did Asa Mercer accomplish this turnaround?

A strong administrator, dedicated teachers focused on a common vision, good curriculum, a belief that every student can achieve and really hard work.

This is exactly what I found in the schools I visited last month in New York City. And although Mercer is a regular public school, they've found the same answer to the same problems as the charter schools I've visited. Not surprisingly, the principal at Mercer was a former teacher at a NYC charter school.

What this shows is that there's no secret to successful schools. Nor is there a shortcut.

It also shows what happens when we learn from what works – no matter where it's working – and apply it to other schools. 

Our students deserve no less.