What to do when you need someone to tell you what to do.

2BCvkIBy Mark

If you were not aware already, the way we teachers are going to be evaluated in the state of Washington is undergoing change. (I've mentioned it here at SfS twice before: first here, and then a follow up here.)

After a recent staff meeting, the WEA teaching staff in my building was asked to cast a vote between one of two options for "frameworks" upon which our future evaluations would be based in our district. Because people have heard I've been involved with a TPEP workgroup, every few steps I took after the meeting, someone said to me "just tell me, which one should I vote for?"

With all due respect to my colleauges, who I love and I know were horribly over-worked having just finished the frantic rush of sleepless nights that is semester finals, this very question is a symptom of a critical problem I think many teachers face.

In the years that I've written posts here at StoriesfromSchool, my topics have tended to focus on a smaller sphere than my long-time colleagues such as Kristin and Tom (Tom's scope has taken him all the way to the Pakistan, after all). I tend to be very focused on my own classroom or local issues, while I turn to other teacher leaders to help me keep abreast of issues of broader statewide or national consequence.

I have long relied upon more articulate, more passionate, more experienced members of my profession to tell me what to think. I've trusted that others will make decisions for me and make their voice heard as mine by proxy. I'm involved in workgroups and panels and committees, but in terms of politics I've done my advocating via phone call, email, and even old-fashioned pen and ink letters. All of these are good and necessary, but I realize that it is only one step above asking other people which way I should vote on the framework that will shape my future evaluations.

When I think about my classroom, my goal is never to take my lowest reader and make him my highest. Baby steps, small bites, little gains: those are the keys to my and my students' success.

So how do I get those who asked me to decide for them to take the next baby step up on advocacy for our profession? I know I am only comfortable with baby steps as well: the relative comfort of phone calls, emails and letters must give way to the face-to-face meetings that are so necessary to advocate for students and teachers. I am picky, though. Like many teachers, saying "no" is not my strong suit, so I intend to pick and choose where I get involved.

Thus, I've been trying to think of a "continuum" of involement…a kind of stair-step guide that might help a reticent teacher step-by-step toward becoming an advocate for our profession at a broader level. By no means should we expect all teachers to race to the top (rimshot+crash). For some, the first few levels will be a stretch for the time being–but as with our students, growth is important.

Here's my shot at it. In the comments, please suggest revisions, additions, or resources for novice education advocates.

Level Zero: Stay focused on your students, but find yourself occasionally caught by surprise when new policies and laws affect you.

Level One: Inform yourself about statewide issues; and consider WEA-PAC's take

Level Two: Go to lunch. See what your colleagues know and think. Start conversations. Help those around you be informed and encourage them to move to the next level with you.

Level Three: Consider how the legislature itself suggests you get involved (there are parallels to my list, though I promise I didn't plagiarize).

Level Four: Give yourself permission to not do it all. Don't expect yourself to fight for every cause. Prioritize which issues you feel are most critical to you and your students. Me: I'm focused on this, among a few. 

Level Five: Figure out who needs to hear your voice, and write a professional email. Sometimes they reply and start a dialogue, which is nice. The WEA site "Our Voice" has some great resources.

Level Six: Consider joining the masses at a rally or gathering. There is safety, and strength, in numbers.

Level Seven: Make an appointment. This is one way to stay local but still get a message across.

Level Eight: Testify before a committee (this is a post from long ago, but nicely recounts Kelly's experience with testifying about an issue of perpetual concern). This is something I've never done, and something which, frankly, terrifies me. But, it needs to be done and I appreciate every other educator who has ever taken on this brave and noble civic involvement.

To me, there are a few huge leaps…Level Five to Level Six feels like a huge jump from the comfort zone I so appreciate.

What would you add? At what level are most of your colleagues…and you?

5 thoughts on “What to do when you need someone to tell you what to do.

  1. Travis A. Wittwer

    I find that daily, level 3 or 4 is where I am. Professionally, level 5 or 6. Part of me would like to be able to do more. Part of me feels that I should not have to constantly battle, and battle on my own time. Believe it or not Washington, I have a family, outside interests, and a life … Oh yea, 120 Of Mice and Men essays to read, provide Relavent/Differentiated/Specific feedback, and return in a timely manner. Let’s see, if I spend 20 minutes on each essay … Yikes.
    I think Washington should just decide if education is important or not and fund or not fund. Stop playing games and putting on shiney statements of education being important and then treating it like an after-thought. Either it is or is not important.
    Mark, can we get a scale that goes to 11? :0)

  2. Mark

    Tom, the tiredness factor is reality.
    That’s why I think it is so important to give ourselves permission to not save the whole world. In a past life I was an overachiever to a fault… so my instinct is that if I can’t do it all I shouldn’t do it at all. Simply being informed and being willing to dive a little deeper into one, maybe two, key issues rather than to take them all on…that’s the only way I can stay sane.

  3. Mark

    Something that I wasn’t able to shoehorn in was simply being involved. I think sometimes I feel like political advocacy looks “one way.” There are lots of little opportunities here and there…task forces, local, ESD or regional committees, think tanks, workgroups…these are places where policy is influenced and shaped even if the people in these spheres aren’t always elected officials/lawmakers.
    There have been several times that I’ve found myself one of only two or three teacher voices in a room full of (well intended) district or higher administrators who genuinely want to make choices that are best for teachers and students–but despite their best intentions sometimes forget to involve teachers, sometimes out of the presumption that teachers are simply too busy and thus don’t want to be involved. It’s not always just about shaping the policy at the legislative level…it is also about how these policies translate into our classrooms through the administrative filter. This is where teacher voice is critical as well.

  4. Tom

    Great post, Mark. One of the ironies of this profession is that even though policymakers need the voice of teachers to make informed policy, the time and energy that it takes to teach practically prohibits most of us from lending our voice.
    I sometimes find myself at some of your upper levels, informing policymakers and others about the realities of teaching, but all the while I secretly want to run back to my third grade classroom, shut the door and teach, without worrying about charter schools, house bills or merit pay.
    Or then there are the days when I wake up ready to change the world. Then I go to work teaching eight year olds. And I come home with almost enough energy to eat dinner.

Comments are closed.